Design Observer

About
Books
Job Board
Newsletters
Archive
Contact



Change Observer

About
Submissions
Contact


Departments

Audio
Bibliography
Case Studies
Collections
Dialogues
Essays
Event-Aspen
Event-Bellagio
Event-Education
Gallery
Interviews
Miscellaneous
New Ideas
Opinions
Primary Sources
Projects
Report
Reviews
Slideshows
Video


Topics

Advertising
Aid
Architecture
Art
Books
Branding
Business
Cities / Places
Community
Craft
Culture
Design History
Design Practice
Development
Disaster Relief
Ecology
Economy
Education
Energy
Environment
Fashion
Film / Video
Food/Agriculture
Geography
Global / Local
Graphic Design
Health / Safety
History
Housing
Ideas
Illustration
India
Industry
Info Design
Infrastructure
Interaction Design
Internet / Blogs
Journalism
Landscape
Media
Motion Design
Museums
Nature
Obituary
Peace
Philanthropy
Photography
Planning
Politics / Policy
Popular Culture
Poverty
Preservation
Product Design
Public Art
Religion
Science
Shelter
Social Enterprise
Sports
Sustainability
Technology
Theory/Criticism
Transportation
TV / Radio
Typography
Urbanism
Volunteerism
Water


Comments (12) Posted 08.16.10 | PERMALINK | PRINT

Essay

The Town That Corbusier Built


Ashish Nangia


The Open Hand at Le Corbusier's Capitol, Chandigarh, India. Photos: Ashish Nangia

When Le Corbusier, the Swiss-born visionary modernist architect, was commissioned in 1950 to build a new city on the baking plains of South Asia, his brief was to create one “free from the fetters of the past.” This phrase belonged to Jawaharlal Nehru, the forward-looking first prime minister of postcolonial India.

“I have welcomed greatly one experiment,” Nehru would say in 1959, “and that is Chandigarh…. It hits you on the head and makes you think.” Le Corbusier built the city in Punjab after Lahore, the region's capital, was lost to Pakistan in the 1947 partition. The capitol complex, completed in 1960, housed a legislative assembly, high court, secretariat and landscape elements such as the Martyrs’ Memorial (a sculpture group symbolizing the British Empire’s defeat in India), Tower of Shadows (one of several structures in the area that pay homage to Punjab’s ferocious sun) and Open Hand (a monument that gives form to Chandigarh’s intended economic and cultural vitality). The capitol complex has been hailed as the epitome of modern architecture, though many argued that what postcolonial India really needed was food, shelter and employment for its masses.

While the world struggled with the Cold War, India experimented with a toned-down version of socialist enterprise. It grappled with and overcame numerous crises: famines, wars with neighbors, even a civil emergency. Little of the grisly politics seemed to penetrate to Chandigarh, an empty city with barren streets. And yet, that was to change. The years rolled on and the population increased, the town developed. People bought land, built houses and reveled in the urban plan: abundant green spaces, a panoramic view of the Himalayas, an artificial lake that brought succor in summer. Cars populated the wide roads and streets; institutions of education and research rose to nourish the denizens. Chandigarh’s town planning became an endeavor to be imitated, though the same has not been always true of its architecture. Le Corbusier’s modernist vision of his capitol was no match for political reality. 



Part of the High Court, Chandigarh — a Cubist Painting?

Take the Open Hand, for example. This monument, designed by Le Corbusier but not built until 1972, is an abstract copper-clad “hand” held aloft by a steel column — “open to give, open to receive,” in the architect’s vision. The sculpture swings in the wind, like a gigantic weather vane. At its base, Corbu designed the “Pit of Contemplation” as an area for citizen debates, theater and other aspects of civic life.

For many years, though, the Open Hand was deserted, its surrounds used for cricket matches or as an occasional strolling ground by occupants of nearby villages. Of civic activity, there was none. The only regular visitors were architects and aficionados of Modernism, who came to gaze at this iconic anomaly in the middle of an empty landscape. More recently, a security-conscious local government barred visitors from the capitol who lacked official business there.


Activities at the Open Hand, Winter 2009

Today, however, Chandigarh’s citizens are beginning to wake up to this magnificent structure. A series of initiatives promises to bring life to the capitol and the Open Hand. Hum Log (“We the People”) is a citizens’ initiative working to “reclaim” the Open Hand by organizing street theater, debates and conferences at the venue. (On August 15, India’s Independence Day, it assembled townspeople for a group sing-along of patriotic songs.) Hum Log’s founder, Dr. Gaurav Chhabra, lays emphasis on the relationship of people with architecture, and on the importance of group action. “Participation,” he says, “is the essence. Once people start to participate, the rest follows.” He and his team have collected activists from around the city and beyond to highlight the monument and give visibility to its restricted access.

On January 29, 2010, their efforts paid off. Chandigarh’s government lifted the ban on social gatherings at the Open Hand and allowed it to be open to citizens daily between 10:30 and 3:30. Tourists and other outsiders, however, must still apply to the city’s administration for permission to visit, a burdensome stipulation that Chhabra believes undermines Le Corbusier’s vision.


Ramp at the High Court


View of the Capitol Buildings, Chandigarh

Sangeeta Bagga-Mehta, an associate professor at the Chandigarh College of Architecture, which is housed in a Le Corbusier–designed building, believes in working within the existing regulations to provide easier access for the growing number of visitors who make inquiries. “What has really changed Chandigarh’s position in the eyes of the world is its nomination for World Heritage status,” she says. Though the city’s 2006 placement in the “tentative” category of that elite list still remains to be approved, attention from UNESCO has produced a larger body of international visitors than ever before. Bagga-Mehta doubts that demonstrators at the Open Hand will persuade government officials to drop their security concerns. Rather she suggests that the capitol open a tourist information/interpretation office for issuing passes on the spot.

These days, on a Saturday, when courts are out of session and offices are closed, it is easy to visit the capitol, and even enter some of the buildings. The security apparatus is visible, and permits are still required for the more important buildings. But the capitol can be seen in its somewhat neglected state, a magnificent testament to modern architecture on a par with the Acropolis and Roman Forum. In the tussle over the question of who really “owns” the capitol — citizens or government — something vital has been neglected: the magnificent buildings themselves. It seems that finally Le Corbusier’s Open Hand, constructed for a city “free from the fetters of the past,” is fulfilling its purpose. Modern architecture is winning in this modern city in the most ancient of civilizations.
Share This Story

RELATED POSTS


Journeying through the Sacred Profane


Gendered Arrangements: India


Design and the Social Sector: An Annotated Bibliography


Journeying through the Sacred Profane


Journeying through the Sacred Profane



RSSSubscribe to Comment Feed

Comments (12)   |   JUMP TO MOST RECENT >>

Corbusier was Swiss. He spoke French and lived in France later in his life. But he was Swiss (He is on the 10 CH Note).
Jen
08.17.10 at 12:24

Interesting essay.
Tom
08.17.10 at 03:06

A little less prattle_mindless talk-and more of the architecture and how people live in it , through it, with it.please. Intriguing concept needs photos...We are visual and tactile beings after all. PHOTOS >>>>PHOTOS that show architecture ...
Edie
08.17.10 at 07:29

Photos that show architecture, it seems, will be harder to come by: a friend of mine who visited the town last year wasn't allowed to take photos of, or even get near the assembly building.

The strongest visual recording of the town is likely Alain Tanner's 1966 documentary "Une ville à Chandigarh", where he literally films the town getting built from the ground up, with the population already in place. Highly recommended viewing.
Murat Güneş
08.17.10 at 09:55

Hi Ashish,
Lovely piece of writing depicting the present scenario in Chandigarh.
The initiative to get the Open Hand is on and shall reap positive outcomes within next few months. Do check this for latest details: http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1375554471#!/album.php?aid=240635&id=512869672
There is a video also: http://www.facebook.com/wallofexpression?v=app_2392950137#!/video/video.php?v=473901904672

Its sad that many of the intellectual scholar architects working on Govt departments/colleges would never raise a voice to get Open Hand free for a very mean reason that their jobs might get challenged.

Open hand is a symbolic place for citizens in the HEAD of the city where the pillars of democracy lie. If people r kept out, the democracy is incomplete. Hence the movement to get it free.

Peace n joy, Dr Gaurav Chhabra
Chandigarh
Dr Gaurav Chhabra
08.19.10 at 01:56

Interesting article on the effort to open Chandigarh. Last summer, in London, I saw a fascinating exhibit on Chandigarh at the University of Westminster. The main focus was on original Corbu/Jenneret furniture saved from going to the dump. There were even pieces that visitors could sit in and experience. There was also a very good exhibit on the construction of the city, plus films and video footage. I've hoping to hear that this exhibit had been remounted somewhere more visible.
Deborah
08.19.10 at 01:33

Edie - 'A little less prattle_mindless talk-and more' appreciation for an interesting article that just happened to address different issues than what you desired.

Your hero and mine,
Sean Sean
Sean Sean
08.19.10 at 10:22

Thank you.
Corbu
08.20.10 at 01:37

Ashish Sir,
Corbusier's concepts remembered... bravo ! nice shots there..
Aeshvarya Thakur
08.20.10 at 04:44

The article has whetted my appetite. I would love to visit while on trip to Delhi next spring. Any advice on how to secure permissions and more most welcome!
Chris White
08.22.10 at 02:13

Hi, Thanks for the article. Its nice to hear you say that the city is poised for change. I can't imagine though that it will ever work in quite the way Corbusier intended. The whole modernist aesthetic seems such an anomaly in India, given its climate, its culture.

I lived in Chandigarh for two years in the late 1970s when I was only in class IV. The concrete buildings become unbearably hot in the summer, which is long and intense in India; walk past a row of such buildings in the month of June and you can feel them radiating heat waves...The open public spaces meant for people to congregate seemed especially misconceived...

Last summer I had to visit a part of old Delhi (which was famously called a slum in an early urban planning report on the city). The temperature was over 44 deg celsius. My air-conditioned car wouldn't go through the narrow lanes of old Delhi so I was forced to expose myself to the elements, taking a cycle-rickshaw. Five minutes into the lanes of the old city and the temperature dropped noticeably, the breeze became cooler. Ten minutes later it was positively pleasant. Of course, it was crowded, noisy, messy. It had the tremendous energy, the color and the dynamism that characterizes old Indian cities. It also made a lot of environmental sense to have house built densely close together.

The years I lived in Chandigarh were so dull by comparison. The houses were so big we ever heard one squeak from our neighbors. When the mango trees dropped their fruit, it lay there and rotted! No one came by to collect it. Far too civilized I thought...

I was so relieved to return to Delhi!

I.Raja
11.13.10 at 06:14

Really nice article! Very interesting.
lucky little travelers
03.28.11 at 08:26



LOG IN TO POST A COMMENT
Don't have an account? Create an account. Forgot your password? Click here.

Email


Password




|
Share This Story



ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Ashish Nangia is an architect who specializes in the history of modern and Indian architecture.
More Bio >>

DESIGN OBSERVER JOBS